The 2026 Game Awards nominations have arrived, bringing the usual mix of celebration, surprise, and immediate arguments over what did not make the cut. That response is part of the event's annual rhythm. A voting body made up of more than 100 publications and critics can recognize a huge range of games, but it cannot possibly reflect every community, genre, platform, or style of play equally.
That limitation is particularly visible in a year with a crowded release calendar, long-running live-service games competing with major new launches, and several high-profile franchises returning to the spotlight. Some omissions are less about a game being ignored altogether than where it did, or did not, receive recognition. Others are cases where passionate audiences feel a game's best qualities were left off the ballot.
Even the anticipation around Grand Theft Auto 6 becoming one of the year's most-nominated games before its release has not distracted from the more familiar question: where are the games and categories that seem to have slipped through the cracks?
Embedded X/Twitter post
Embedded X/Twitter post
Embedded X/Twitter post
Best Ongoing Game remains too familiar
The sharpest criticism is aimed at the Best Ongoing Game category itself. This award is meant to honor titles that have sustained and improved their player experience through updates, expansions, and continued support. Yet its 2026 list again leans heavily toward repeat nominees: Arc Raiders, The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt, Final Fantasy XIV, Fortnite, and No Man's Sky.
For useful background on this topic, read Former Take-Two CEO Says AI Games Need a 'Toy Story Moment' to Win Over Players.
There is little doubt that Final Fantasy XIV, Fortnite, and No Man's Sky have established records of substantial support. Their frequent presence also speaks to the loyalty these games have earned over years of development. But the repetition creates a larger problem. If many of the same games occupy the category annually, it can appear that voters are rewarding the ongoing games they already play rather than surveying the full ecosystem of games that had meaningful years.
The category is also broad enough to encompass very different approaches to ongoing support. A major expansion, a systemic overhaul, a seasonal content strategy, a campaign revival, and a substantial increase in playable options can all reshape a game's relationship with its audience. Looking beyond the familiar names would allow the award to better represent that variety.
Overwatch is one of the clearest examples raised in this discussion. Its reboot this year reportedly reworked the game's story direction and added an unprecedented 10 heroes to the roster. For a competitive hero shooter, that level of character expansion can meaningfully alter team compositions, strategies, balance expectations, and the overall pace of play. Whether players remain enthusiastic about Blizzard's shooter or not, its scale of change makes its absence from Best Ongoing Game notable.
World of Warcraft is another long-running game that had a substantial year but did not make the list. The question is not whether every successful service game should receive a nomination. Instead, the concern is that a category designed around evolution should cast a wider net before returning to the same handful of proven nominees.
Marathon's visual identity deserved a closer look
Marathon has been divisive, but division is not the same as a lack of distinction. Bungie's extraction shooter has earned strong appreciation from players who connected with its particular mix of high-stakes multiplayer design and science-fiction atmosphere. That makes its absence from Best Art Direction especially surprising.
Art Direction is often where games with bold aesthetics can receive recognition regardless of whether they are universally embraced in every other respect. A striking visual language can establish a game's personality before a match even begins, and it can be crucial to communicating a world's tone, factions, technology, threats, and sense of place. For an extraction shooter, visual clarity is also not merely decorative: readable spaces, memorable landmarks, and identifiable gear can support the gameplay loop.
Not every player had the chance to spend time with Marathon, and not everyone who did came away enthusiastic. Still, the game's look has been one of its most commonly praised attributes. Its omission suggests that the awards conversation may have focused more on its polarized reception than on a craft category where its strengths were easier to identify.
Crimson Desert earned only a community support nod
Crimson Desert, Pearl Abyss' fantasy action RPG, did make the nominations list--but only for Best Community Support. That is recognition worth having, particularly for a game that cultivated a committed audience. But for players who connected with its ambitious action and fantasy world, a single nomination feels limited.
The game's complicated controls appear to have been a barrier for some. A demanding or unconventional control scheme can be difficult to overcome, especially in an action RPG where players expect immediate fluency with combat, traversal, menus, and progression systems. If that friction turned away some voters early, it could explain why the game did not break through more broadly.
At the same time, a game that asks more of players can build a particularly dedicated following among those who learn its systems. The response from people who enjoyed Crimson Desert indicates that it found that audience. Its community support nomination recognizes that relationship, but the lack of broader category representation leaves open the possibility that the game's deeper appeal was underestimated during awards deliberations.
Fire Emblem: Fortune's Weave is an unusual fit for one nomination
Nintendo games often perform well during awards season, which makes the limited recognition for Fire Emblem: Fortune's Weave stand out. The new entry received a nomination in Best RPG, an appropriate category for a series rooted in character-building, tactical encounters, and long-form storytelling. But it did not receive a Strategy nomination.
That omission is unusual when placed beside the franchise's recent history. Fire Emblem: Three Houses and Fire Emblem Engage were both nominated in the Strategy category in their respective years. The series has always existed at the intersection of RPG progression and tactical strategy, so it is reasonable to expect a new entry to be considered in both spaces.
A single RPG nomination does not mean the game was dismissed. It does, however, narrow the picture of what Fortune's Weave represents. The appeal of Fire Emblem is not solely its role-playing elements; its positioning, class choices, turn-by-turn planning, and risk management are fundamental to the series' identity. Leaving it out of Strategy reduces the visibility of that half of the formula.
Gears of War: E-Day missed the top-tier conversation
Gears of War: E-Day, the long-awaited prequel to the 2006 original, was not ignored by the nominations. The Coalition's return to the series earned places in Best Action Game, Innovation in Accessibility, and Best Multiplayer. Those are significant acknowledgements, particularly for a franchise whose identity is closely tied to cooperative and competitive play.
For some Xbox fans, however, the missing categories matter as much as the nominations it received. They expected to see Gears of War: E-Day in the Game of the Year lineup and have also questioned why it was not recognized for art direction or voice performance. In particular, fans have highlighted the absence of a nomination for Marcus' voice actor.
This is a familiar awards-season tension. A game can earn multiple technical or genre nominations while still being absent from the prestige categories that shape the public narrative around the year. For supporters of E-Day, its place as a prequel to such an important Xbox series made it feel like more than a solid action release. They saw it as a major franchise moment that should have been represented among the year's biggest honors.
Best Adaptation has sparked another movie argument
The Best Adaptation category has become one of the most subjective awards on the ballot because it asks voters to compare projects across very different media and tones. This year's argument centers on the absence of the Street Fighter movie, which was left off the nominations while The Super Mario Galaxy Movie made the list.
The case for Street Fighter is not necessarily that it was a conventional prestige adaptation. Its supporters value its messy, exaggerated, and knowingly strange qualities--the kind of movie experience that can become memorable precisely because of its outsized commitment to spectacle. That kind of appeal does not always translate cleanly to a voting process that may favor polished, broadly accessible adaptations.
The frustration is intensified by last year's Best Adaptation debate, when Sonic the Hedgehog 3 was excluded and The Last of Us season two won. Awards are not a definitive measurement of cultural value, but repeat controversies make clear that audiences do not all want the same thing from an adaptation. Some prioritize faithful storytelling and critical prestige. Others want energy, entertainment, personality, and a stronger understanding of why the original game became beloved.
Snubs are inevitable, but category choices still matter
No awards show can include every deserving game. Limited nominee slots force difficult choices, and the resulting ballot will always reflect the tastes and priorities of the people casting votes. That does not make criticism pointless. On the contrary, debates around omissions can reveal which genres, communities, and forms of craft receive less consistent attention.
The 2026 nominations have highlighted a recurring issue: broad categories need broad consideration. Best Ongoing Game should look beyond its usual rotation. Art Direction should be able to recognize a visually confident game even when its reception is complicated. Strategy games should not lose their tactical identity simply because they also qualify as RPGs. And Best Adaptation needs room for projects that succeed through wild entertainment as well as prestige.
Whether players are defending Overwatch, Marathon, Crimson Desert, Fire Emblem: Fortune's Weave, Gears of War: E-Day, or the Street Fighter movie, the common point is simple: a nomination list is never the complete story of a year in games. The most compelling omissions are reminders of just how much ground any single awards show has to cover.
Community
Discussion
Start the conversation.
No comments have been posted yet.